Critiquing GC Spivak’s ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’


Chanchal Kumar

chanchal kumarAnybody who has tried reading 'Can the Subaltern Speak?' will accede to the fact that it is a text rooted in the academic discourse. Perhaps that's the reason why the ideas propounded therein are still considered to be unchallenged, or at least impossible to ignore. I am undertaking the task to bust a few myths surrounding the logic of this essay by Dr Spivak, and I realize I may not be perfect in doing so. My attempt is rather an effort to anticipate more engagements with Dr Spivak's work through the lens of Bahujan thought. This is my intention behind writing this critique.

Let's now delve into what I think is the central flaw in Spivak's writing. She starts her seminal work by calling attention to her own positionality as a woman in a world of western thought hitherto dominated by men: she starts by naming Althusser in the first paragraph and continues to mention Derrida and Marx in the second, and the reader is assured that it is going to be an easy win for Spivak, who is not only a woman but also a Brown woman with roots in India. Until someone who her kins suppress and exploit does not rise to talk back to her, she will remain unchallenged in the world of academic thought.

Throughout the essay, and around most of her career, Spivak has taken on the role of the poor, weak Brown Indian woman oppressed by men from Europe and America, while expertly hiding the fact that she herself belongs to the elite Bengali Brahmin caste which has oppressed, and continues to oppress millions of people in South Asia. Through an elaborate trick, she hoodwinks the entire world into believing that the Brahmin woman is the most oppressed section of population on the Earth. The truth, in actuality, is something just the reverse of what she wants everyone to believe. By constantly naming and engaging with Eurocentric thought, and building her arguments on the grave of the most acclaimed western philosopher Derrida, she emerges as the lone surviving warrior who can take on such heavyweights as the names mentioned above. Now, considering that academia is dominated either by White or Brahmin men, Spivak's primacy as a renowned scholar is confirmed.

Let's now shuffle through the chaff and get into the narrative that Spivak builds into Can the Subaltern Speak. Just as she builds her argument after destroying the validity, in a sense, of the Western academics, similarly she upholds the primacy of the Bengali Brahmin woman. She speaks of a martyr woman during India's freedom struggle who died by suicide during the time she was menstruating. This served a double purpose, that of proving her chastity and sacrificing her life for the cause of the nation. This historical incident confirms her thesis according to her, that the "subaltern" cannot speak. The subaltern can only convey their message through their body, after they are no more alive.

The questions that should be put forward to Dr Spivak are as follows: How can she, being of the oppressor Bengali Brahmin caste, pass a judgment condemning the lives of the marginalized and those without agency? What does she know about the experiences of the oppressed being from the dominant caste herself? Is this not a case of the Brahmins being cruelly insensitive to the aspirations and dreams of millions of the poor and impoverished? Isn't she trying to determine the futures of people she has never seen and does not in the least know? In her recent interview, Spivak mentions how she has undertaken the task of educating children from the most underprivileged sections of rural Bengal.

My question is, why do Brahmins always feel the need to play saviors of those who oppress? Why can't they first see to it that their own house is in order, to borrow a phrase from Black thought. When the entire world is undergoing a process of introspection and realizing the effects their actions have on others, why do people like Spivak pretend to be above human standards of right and wrong? Does she really believe to be a bhu-deva, or a God on Earth, who everybody must worship and appease? If she does, then it is high time she consult a psychiatrist who will help her find the human side of her personality. We, Ambedkarite Buddhists have had enough of the tantrums and wishful thinking of these self-appointed guardians of humanity. We are here to assert that we are capable enough to take care of ourselves.



 Chanchal Kumar is from Jharkhand and currently lives in Delhi, India. His poems have previously appeared and awarded in The Sunflower Collective, Hamilton Stone Review, Welter Journal, Name and None, Young Poets Network, UK including others. Recently, his poems were translated to Bengali by Harakiri Journal. He is pursuing M.Phil at University of Delhi.

Other Related Articles

The caste view of 'saffron dollars'
Saturday, 27 November 2021
  Dr. Bhushan Amol Darkase "If anyone throws his glance at the Indian physical and social world as a spectator, he will undoubtedly find this country a home of glaring inequality." -Dr Ambedkar... Read More...
Buddhist Sangha — an embodiment of gender neutrality
Wednesday, 24 November 2021
  Dr Amritpal Kaur  When an ideology for restructuring of human nature and society becomes a religious cult, it not only loses its spirit of rationality and political relevance and its... Read More...
Waatavaran’s ‘Adivasis for Forests’ Initiative
Friday, 19 November 2021
  Waatavaran's 'Adivasis for Forests' Initiative In Partnership With Raigad Administration Receives International Support Rahul Sawant "The larger goal of the Adivasis for Forest is management... Read More...
The revival of 'public conscience'
Thursday, 18 November 2021
  Dr. Bhushan Amol Darkase The survival of Indian democracy depends on the revival of 'public conscience' which Dr. Ambedkar explained as, 'Conscience which becomes agitated at every wrong,... Read More...
Narratives of Dalit Cultural Politics in Telangana
Tuesday, 16 November 2021
   Bhangya Bhukya Vemula Yellaiah's Kakka which was published in Telugu, twenty years ago and now translated in English is a powerful narrative of dalit assertion in Telangana. It is the... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Govt. of India should send One Lakh SC ST youths abroad for Higher Education
Monday, 21 June 2021
  Anshul Kumar Men sitting on the pinnacle of the palace "So, I went one day to Linlithgow and said, concerning the expense of education, "If you will not get angry, I want to ask a question. I... Read More...
Reflections On Contemporary Navayana Buddhism - Context, Debates and Theories
Tuesday, 10 August 2021
  The Shared Mirror    PRE RELEASE COPY Reflections on Contemporary Navayāna Buddhism Context, Debates and Theories     Shaileshkumar Darokar Subodh Wasnik bodhi s.r ... Read More...
Conceiving a New Public: Ambedkar on Universities
Saturday, 26 June 2021
Asha Singh & Nidhin Donald Dr. B.R. Ambedkar conceptualizes education as a ‘vital need’ which helps us fight notions of ‘inescapable fate’ or ‘ascriptions of caste or religion’. He... Read More...
Caste management through feminism in India
Friday, 06 August 2021
Kanika S There was a time some 5-6 years ago when feminism tried to undermine Dr Ambedkar by pointing out that he carried a penis.1 Now he is just as fantastically a carrier of feminist ideals... Read More...
Rainbow casteism and racism in the queer community is alienating us
Monday, 28 June 2021
  Sophia I entered the Delhi queer movement in my early 20s, as a complete outsider in terms of language, origin, race, class, and caste identity. I wanted to bring change to the status quo and... Read More...